Cheap Rates on Hotels, Airfare & Car Rentals...
- Sign In
- Sign In for Member Deals!
-
Currency: USD ($)
USD ($)
Cheap Rates on Hotels, Airfare & Car Rentals...
x
OR
Not Registered?
Register now to unlock member only deals Member only deals on select inventory.
Instantly create an account & Save Big!
Create an Account
Already have an account?
Back to Sign In
Reset password
Please enter the email address you signed up with and we'll immediately email you a link to reset your password.
Remember your password?
Back to Sign In
Search Hotels in and near Shelter Island
Top 9 Hotels in and near Shelter Island, New York, United States
Select a data range for Shelter Island Hotel Rates & availability
The Pridwin Hotel
81 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964, USA
Property Type Hotel
Property Highlights Beachfront Private Beach Outdoor Pool Restaurant Watersports
Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 1.91 Miles away from Shelter Island center
Topping Rose House
1 Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Turnpike, Bridgehampton, NY 11932, USA
Located in picturesque Bridgehampton Topping Rose House is the Hamptons first full-service luxury hotel. We offer elegantly appointed guest rooms a historic Barn for private events and a restaurant featuring locally sourced products as well as ingredients from our on site one acre farm. Open year round we provide our guests the utmost in comfort...
Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 9.19 Miles away from Shelter Island center
Sunset Beach
35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965, USA
Sunset Beach is a relaxing hideaway on secluded Shelter Island. The exquisite 20 room seasonal hotel has a charming restaurant and bar where you can take in the stunning sunset views across the picturesque Peconic Bay. Inspired by the Italian and French Rivieras - Sunset Beach is one of the most unique and beloved Long Island retreats.
Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 1.45 Miles away from Shelter Island center
Forever Bungalows
765 RT 114, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, USA
Forever Bungalows is a simple environment that encourages a true escape Our hotel rooms have a quiet boutique feel while our detached bungalows offer a more casual country vibe Great WIFi killer AC Cable All of the rooms have larger than mini fridges and the bungalows have small kitchens for light cooking A straight 15 miles from the very...
Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 6.48 Miles away from Shelter Island center
The Harborfront Inn
209 Front Street, Greenport, NY 11944, USA
Property Type Hotel
Property Highlights Outdoor Pool Fitness Center Concierge Service
Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 2.62 Miles away from Shelter Island center
East Hampton Point Inn
295 Three Mile Harbor Hog Creek Rd, East Hampton, NY 11937, USA
The Hotel was constructed in 1890 and was remodeled in 2004. Lexington Services - - Spotlight - - Complimentary Continental Breakfast - Complimentary Local Shuttle - Complimentary Outdoor Parking - - W E L C O M E - East Hampton Point Cottages And Suites Invites Its Guests To Partake In Both The Breathtaking Marina Waters And The Serenity...
Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 8.90 Miles away from Shelter Island center
Shelter Island House
11 Stearns Point Road, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965, USA
Property Location With a stay at Shelter Island House in Shelter Island Heights, you'll be next to a golf course and minutes from Shelter Island Country Club and Crescent Beach. This hotel is within close proximity of PdJ Boards Stand Up Paddle Boarding and Shelter Island Tennis Club. Rooms Make yourself at home in one of the 11 air-conditioned...
Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 1.18 Miles away from Shelter Island center
Barons Cove
31 W. Water Street, Sag Harbor, NY 11963, USA
Just a short walk from Main Street in the historic village of Sag Harbor Barons Cove will be a perfect base for exploring the Hamptons the Peconic Bay and all of the beaches dining shopping and culture that Eastern Long Island offers. Currently undergoing an extensive renovation the finished resort will offer vacationers an ideal location...
Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 5.09 Miles away from Shelter Island center
380 Inn
380 Montauk Hwy, Wainscott, NY 11975, USA
the 380 inn located between bridgehampton sag harbor and easthampton villages is the hub of the hamptons for shopping and culinary enjoyment. This 20 unit hotel with deluxe rooms with kitchenettes and rustic cabins with kitchenettes lends itself to the perfect hamptons getaway. Nestled in lush landscaped grounds it has a swimming pool which...
Select Date Range for Rates & Availability
Check Rates & Availability
Check-In: Select a date range
Check-Out:Select a date range
Upvote
Downvote
Approximately 9.50 Miles away from Shelter Island center
Best Shelter Island Hotels - Map View
Shelter Island Frequently Asked Questions
Question: How's the seasonal weather in Shelter Island?
Answer: Shelter Island Seasonal temperature break down - The average median temperature March through May is approximately 46°F with highs averaging at 56°F and lows averaging at 37°F. June through August has an approximate average median temperature of 69°F with highs averaging at 80°F, lows typically average at 59°F. Average median temperatures September through November average out at 53°F, high temperatures average out at 63°F and lows average at 42°F. The average median temperature December through February is approximately 33°F with highs averaging at 42°F, lows average out at 24°F. The average Shelter Island annual median temperature averages out at approximately 50°F. The coldest month in Shelter Island is January with a median temperature of 31°F, the average high for the month of January is 40°F with an average low of 21°F. The hottest month in Shelter Island is July with an approximate median temperature of 73°F, the average high for the month of July is 84°F with an average low of 63°F.
Question: What type of clothing should I pack for my trip to Shelter Island?
Answer: If you plan on traveling to Shelter Island from March through May you will want to pack a couple of lightweight long sleeve shirts and lightweight jeans or pants. You will also want to think about packing a lightweight jacket or a lightweight sweater for the cooler days or nights. Those of you who will be traveling to Shelter Island from June through August should think about packing some short sleeve shirts and shorts. You may also want to pack a tank top as it can sometimes get pretty hot during the day. You should also consider packing a lightweight long sleeve shirt and jeans as there's a possibility you can run into a cooler night. Folks that will be traveling to Shelter Island September through November may want to consider packing a couple of long sleeve shirts and jeans, you will also want to consider packing a lightweight jacket. Those of you that will be traveling to Shelter Island from December through February will want to pack a number of heavy sweaters, long sleeve shirts, jeans, gloves, a heavy jacket, ear muffs will also be a good idea.
Question: Where can I get a bite to eat during my Shelter Island stay?
Answer: Shelter Island has a decent amount of places to eat at please see the following list of our top choices of places to eat during your stay in Shelter Island.
Question: Where can I party or get a round of drinks with the buddies during our Shelter Island visit?
Answer: Please feel free to have a look.
Places To Eat At - During Your Shelter Island Visit
Restaurants
The Islander -
Restaurant -
Shelter Island,
New York
Commander Codys Seafood -
Seafood Restaurant -
Shelter Island,
New York
Sweet Tomatos -
Restaurant -
Shelter Island Heights,
New York
Dory -
Restaurant -
Shelter Island Heights,
New York
